ER Level 4 vs Level 5 (99284 vs 99285): What Your ER Bill's Level Means
Published by BillCheck. Sources: ACEP, American College of Cardiology, HHS, CMS (full list).
Published · Last reviewed · 9 min read
Level 4 (CPT 99284) means the ER doctor's medical decision making was moderate. Level 5 (CPT 99285) means it was high. Since January 1, 2023, time doesn't count toward the doctor's ER level, so a long wait doesn't make a visit level 5. The hospital bills its own facility level, and each hospital sets its own rules for that.
You went to the ER, got checked out, and went home. Then the bill arrived with "Level 5" or the code 99285 on it — the highest level there is. Is that right?
Sometimes it is. Sometimes it's worth a question. This guide explains what the levels actually measure, why the rules changed in 2023, why you often get two different levels for the same visit, and how to ask the billing office to show its work.
What are the five ER visit levels?
Emergency department visits are billed with one of five evaluation and management (E/M) codes, from 99281 (level 1) to 99285 (level 5). Higher levels are paid more. On a hospital bill you might see the code, the word "Level," or a description like "ER visit high complexity."
The fight is almost always between level 4 (99284) and level 5 (99285), because that's where the definitions get judgment-heavy.
Is the ER level based on how long you were there?
Starting January 1, 2023, the physician's ER level is chosen based exclusively on medical decision making (MDM). The American College of Emergency Physicians' guidance is direct: "Time is not a descriptive component for the emergency department levels of E/M services." The history and physical exam still need to be medically appropriate and documented, but they no longer directly determine the code.
That cuts both ways for patients:
- A four-hour wait doesn't make a visit level 5. Waiting isn't decision making.
- A quick visit can still be level 5 if the doctor had to rule out something dangerous and made a high-risk decision — for example, about whether to admit you.
What is medical decision making (MDM)?
MDM is scored on three elements:
- Problems addressed — how many and how serious.
- Data reviewed and analyzed — tests ordered or reviewed, outside records, history from someone else, discussion with another clinician.
- Risk of patient management — how risky the treatment options and decisions were.
Each element is graded from minimal up to high. To qualify for a given level, two of the three elements must be met or exceeded.
What counts as level 4 (99284)?
ACEP's MDM grid gives examples of what moderate looks like: for problems, "1 or more chronic illnesses with exacerbation, progression, or side effects of treatment"; for risk, "moderate risk of morbidity from additional diagnostic testing or treatment"; for data, satisfying at least one of the data categories.
What counts as level 5 (99285)?
High is a step further. Examples from ACEP's guidance include a problem that is "1 acute or chronic illness or injury that poses a threat to life or bodily function," or "1 or more chronic illnesses with severe exacerbation, progression, or side effects of treatment." On the risk side, ACEP lists a "decision regarding hospitalization or escalation of hospital-level of care" as high risk. High data requires satisfying at least two data categories.
Notice the phrase poses a threat to life or bodily function. That's about what the doctor had to evaluate, not what you turned out to have. Chest pain that turns out to be heartburn may still have required the doctor to work up a possible heart attack. That's why a level 5 can be legitimate even when the final diagnosis sounds minor — and why the documentation matters more than the diagnosis.
BillCheck
Have the itemized ER bill? Upload it and BillCheck flags the visit level, duplicate charges and other lines worth asking about, then drafts a polite letter you send yourself. The preview is free. The full audit and letter cost $19.
Check my bill free →Pay $19 only if you want every issue explained and a draft dispute letter.
Why did I get two ER bills with different levels?
An ER visit usually produces two separate charges:
- The professional fee from the emergency physician (often billed by a physician group, not the hospital). This is the level governed by the MDM rules above.
- The facility fee from the hospital, for the room, nurses, equipment, and staff time.
The facility level follows different rules. According to ACEP, CMS requires each hospital to establish its own facility billing guidelines, and "there is no national standard for hospital assignment of E&M code levels." Facility coding reflects the volume and intensity of hospital resources used, and ACEP notes there is "no definitive strong correlation between facility and professional coding." ACEP offers one model set of facility guidelines that hospitals can use, which assigns levels based on nursing and ancillary staff interventions.
Practical takeaway: you can ask the hospital which facility-level criteria it used for your visit. Because each hospital sets its own, asking for them is a fair question.
How can you check whether your ER level is right?
- Get the itemized bill. You need the actual codes, not a summary. Our free request letter asks for CPT/HCPCS codes, revenue codes, and dates.
- Get the records. Request the emergency physician's note and the nursing notes. Under HIPAA, providers must generally act on your request within 30 calendar days, with one possible 30-day extension if they explain the delay in writing.
- Read the medical decision making section. Look for what the doctor was worried about (the "differential diagnosis"), what tests were ordered or reviewed, and any decisions about admission, transfer, or high-risk medications.
- Compare it to the definitions. Does the note show at least two of the three MDM elements at the high level? If the note describes a simple problem, a test or two, and a low-risk prescription, a level 5 is worth asking about.
- Check your EOB. If you're insured, your EOB shows what the insurer allowed for each code and what you owe. Make sure the provider isn't billing you more than the EOB's patient responsibility.
How do you ask the hospital to review an ER level?
Billing offices respond better to specific questions than to accusations. Keep the letter short:
"I'm writing about account [number] for my emergency visit on [date], which was billed at level 5 (CPT 99285). Based on my records, I'd like to understand the basis for this level. Please explain how the level was determined, provide the facility-level criteria used if applicable, and conduct a coding review. Please hold this account and do not refer it to collections while the review is pending."
Send it to both the hospital (facility level) and the physician group (professional level) if both are billed at level 5. Keep copies and note dates. If you're insured and the claim has been processed, you can also ask your insurer whether it reviewed the level.
If they confirm the level, ask what documentation supports it. If they correct it, ask for a revised statement and make sure the change also flows through to your insurer. For the full dispute workflow, see how to dispute a hospital bill.
Free tool
Was the ER doctor out-of-network? For most private insurance, the No Surprises Act limits emergency bills to your in-network cost-sharing — even from out-of-network doctors at the hospital. Our free checker tells you in a minute whether you're likely protected.
Check your ER bill →What else should you check on an ER bill?
- Out-of-network emergency providers. Under the No Surprises Act, CMS says you can't be charged more than your in-network cost-sharing for emergency services by the hospital or the providers who treat you, and you can't be asked to waive that protection for emergency care.
- Ambulance charges. The rules differ for air and ground ambulances — see our ambulance bill guide.
- Denied claims. If your insurer denied the ER visit (for example, as "not an emergency"), that's an appeal, with a deadline. See appeal deadlines by plan type.
- Can't afford it? Nonprofit hospitals must have a financial assistance policy that covers emergency care. See our charity care guide.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a level 4 and level 5 ER visit?
Does a long wait in the ER mean a higher level?
Why did I get two bills for one ER visit?
How do I get my ER records to check the level?
Can I dispute a level 5 ER charge?
Sources
- ACEP: 2023 ED E/M guidelines FAQs
- ACEP: 2023 MDM grid (PDF)
- ACEP Now: 2023 documentation guideline changes for ED E/M codes 99281–99285
- American College of Cardiology: Elements of medical decision making
- ACEP: ED facility level coding guidelines
- HHS: How timely must a covered entity be in responding to access requests?
- CMS: Your medical bill rights when using insurance
This guide is general information, not legal, medical, or financial advice. Rules change and your plan documents, state law, and the notices you receive control your situation. For decisions with real stakes, talk to a qualified professional. BillCheck is an AI-assisted self-help tool, not a law firm or a billing advocate.